1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21
1 / 50
50 photos

1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21

Medora, Muskoka Lakes, ON
Listed today
$10,495,000For Sale
$4,034,876Estimated value
4Bedrooms
3Bathrooms
3500-5000 sqftSize
1320 ft × 380 ftLot Size
DetachedProperty Type

1 ONAWAY ISLAND R21

Muskoka Lakes, ON · Medora

Listed today
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms3
Size3500-5000 sqft
Lot Size1320 ft × 380 ft
Property TypeDetached
$10,495,000
For Sale
MLS# X13493762
$4,034,876Estimated value

Polsinello Voice Concierge

Get answers about this home

Ask anything about this home or book a viewing — instantly.

About this home

Welcome to Onaway Island. This extraordinary property, a true crown jewel in the heart of Muskoka, offers a one-of-a-kind lifestyle, blending the warmth and character of a classic Canadian lodge with the timeless charm of Americana. Set on over 2 acres of a private island with an impressive 1320 feet of frontage, this offering is truly unmatched in its beauty, privacy, and classic elegance. The 4-bedroom cottage, boasting breathtaking views from every room and porch, is a masterpiece of design, where bark-stripped columnsand exposed rafter tails exude a character unrivalled in today's construction. A hand-built custom fireplace, a beautiful Muskoka room,and a separate master wing with a private ensuite provide an idyllic retreat. Outside, the island's natural beauty shines with sunrise-to-…

Features & Details

Property Type
Detached
Tax
$19,972 / 2025
Building Age
16-30 years
Size
3500-5000 sqft
Lot Size
1320 x 380 Feet
Basement Info
None
Total Parking Spaces
0
Title
Residential Freehold
Property Style
Bungalow
Community
Medora
Municipality
Muskoka Lakes
Construction
Wood
Cross Street
South Lake Rosseau by Boat
Front Door Facing
North
Local Amenities
Golf
Lot Legal Description
ONAWAY ISLAND IN LAKE ROSSEAU MEDORA; MUSKOKA LAKES
Data Source
One Point Association of REALTORS
Brokerage
Chestnut Park Real Estate
Listed On
Jun 26, 2026
Listing Expires On
Sep 30, 2026
Listing Updated On
Jun 26, 2026
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3
Kitchens
1
Rooms
12
Bathroom Detail
1 Pc on Main Level
Bathroom Detail
2 Pcs on Main Level
Garage Type
None
Parking
0
Heating
Forced Air
Heat Source
Propane
Cooling
Central Air
Sewer
Septic
Swimming Pool
None
Roof Material
Cedar
Foundation Type
Concrete
Interior Features
Guest Accommodations, Primary Bedroom - Main Floor, Generator - Full

Listing History

ActiveListed todayCurrently viewingMLS #X13493762
Jun 26, 2026yesterday
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view
Listed for Sale668 days on marketMLS #X10436418
Aug 28, 20241 year ago
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view

Estimate History

Estimated value, last 24 months
Jul 2024 – Jun 2026
$5.53M
$4.06M
$2.59M
$1.12M
Jul
Dec
May
Oct
Mar
Jun

Automated estimate from Polsinello Predictive AI. Not an appraisal. Actual market value may differ.

Mortgage calculator

Estimated monthly payment
$51,200

Estimated payment. Does not include property tax, insurance, or condo fees.

Location & nearby

Medora Real Estate Market

Muskoka Lakes · last 90 days
$1,100,000
Median sold price
24 days
Avg days on market
29
Homes sold (90 days)
14%
Sold above asking
79%
Sold below asking
$940–$1,218/ft²
Price per sq ft
Median price trend
Jul 2025 – Jun 2026
$5.61M
$3.85M
$2.09M
$0.33M
Jul
Sep
Nov
Feb
Apr
Jun

Similar homes

1099 Big Joe Road
For Sale
1 / 31
$8,590,000
25 days ago
1099 Big Joe Road
Muskoka Lakes
3 bd 4 ba 2 parking
Detached · MLS® X13232182
1158 Ranwood Road
For Sale
1 / 50
$8,949,000
73 days ago
1158 Ranwood Road
Muskoka Lakes
2 bd 8 ba 4 parking
Detached · MLS® X13005728
1422 Barlochan Road
For Sale
1 / 49
$8,990,000
48 days ago
1422 Barlochan Road
Muskoka Lakes
3 bd 4 ba 8 parking
Detached · MLS® X13110292
1246 Purdy Road
For Sale
1 / 18
$8,999,000
94 days ago
1246 Purdy Road
Muskoka Lakes
4 bd 2 ba 8 parking
Other · MLS® X12925292
1158 Pine Needle Point Road
For Sale
1 / 23
$9,850,000
25 days ago
1158 Pine Needle Point Road
Muskoka Lakes
6 bd 6 ba 8 parking
Detached · MLS® X13236310
1118 Shamrock Road
For Sale
1 / 50
$9,899,000
10 days ago
1118 Shamrock Road
Muskoka Lakes
9 bd 2 ba 6 parking
Detached · MLS® X13462054
(905) 830-9111