5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
5459 Ontario Avenue
1 / 45
45 photos

5459 Ontario Avenue

Downtown, Niagara Falls, ON
Listed 44 days ago
$998,000For Sale
$809,478Estimated value
5+2Bedrooms
6Bathrooms
2500-3000 sqftSize
6Parking
50 ft × 128 ftLot Size
FourplexProperty Type

5459 Ontario Avenue

Niagara Falls, ON · Downtown

Listed 44 days ago
Bedrooms5+2
Bathrooms6
Size2500-3000 sqft
Parking6
Lot Size50 ft × 128 ft
Property TypeFourplex
$998,000
For Sale
MLS# X13132744
$809,478Estimated value

Polsinello Voice Concierge

Get answers about this home

Ask anything about this home or book a viewing — instantly.

About this home

Welcome to 5459 Ontario Ave - A Prime Investment Opportunity in Niagara Falls. Discover a fullystabilized, cash-flowing asset in one of Canada's most iconic tourist destinations. Thisdetached home features five self-contained 1-bedroom suites and one 2-bedroom suite, offeringsix fully rented units - each partially furnished and occupied by reliable tenants whoconsistently pay on time. Situated on a 50 x 127 ft. lot, this well-maintained propertyincludes two non-conforming basement apartments and rear parking for six vehicles. It providesa turnkey investment with strong rental performance and minimal ongoing management. PropertyHighlights include six fully leased units producing strong, consistent income. Excellenttenants in good standing with a history of on-time payment. 200-amp electrica…

Features & Details

Property Type
Fourplex
Tax
$6,170 / 2025
Building Age
51-99 years
Size
2500-3000 sqft
Lot Size
50.12 x 127.88 Feet
Basement Info
Apartment, Finished
Total Parking Spaces
6
Title
Residential Freehold
Property Style
2-Storey
Community
Downtown
Municipality
Niagara Falls
Construction
Aluminum Siding
Cross Street
Niagara River Pkwy & Eastwood Cres
Front Door Facing
North
Lot Legal Description
LT 27 PL 328 NIAGARA FALLS; NIAGARA FALLS
Data Source
Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Brokerage
RE/MAX EXPERTS
Listed On
May 15, 2026
Listing Expires On
Jul 15, 2026
Listing Updated On
Jun 17, 2026
Bedrooms
5+2
Bathrooms
6
Kitchens
4
Rooms
13
Garage Type
None
Parking
6
Heating
Water
Heat Source
Gas
Cooling
None
Sewer
Sewer
Swimming Pool
None
Roof Material
Asphalt Shingle
Foundation Type
Concrete
Interior Features
None

Listing History

Active44 days on marketCurrently viewingMLS #X13132744
May 15, 20261 month ago
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view
Listed for Sale165 days on marketMLS #X12695386
Jan 14, 20265 months ago
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view

Estimate History

Estimated value, last 24 months
Jul 2024 – Jun 2026
$867K
$818K
$768K
$718K
Jul
Dec
May
Oct
Mar
Jun

Automated estimate from Polsinello Predictive AI. Not an appraisal. Actual market value may differ.

Mortgage calculator

Estimated monthly payment
$4,869

Estimated payment. Does not include property tax, insurance, or condo fees.

Location & nearby

Downtown Real Estate Market

Niagara Falls · last 90 days
$385,000
Median sold price
42 days
Avg days on market
21
Homes sold (90 days)
5%
Sold above asking
86%
Sold below asking
$263–$373/ft²
Price per sq ft
Median price trend
Jul 2025 – Jun 2026
$604K
$508K
$411K
$314K
Jul
Oct
Jan
Apr
Jun

Similar homes

3533 Dorchester Road
For Sale
1 / 45
$799,000
33 days ago
3533 Dorchester Road
Niagara Falls
3 bd 3 ba 1 parking
Detached · MLS® X13205954
8253 Costabile Drive
For Sale
1 / 22
$799,000
51 days ago
8253 Costabile Drive
Niagara Falls
3 bd 2 ba 2 parking
Detached · MLS® X13106652
9150 Willoughby Drive
For Sale
1 / 47
$799,000
67 days ago
9150 Willoughby Drive
Niagara Falls
2 bd 3 ba 2 parking
Common Element Condo · MLS® X13037800
5124 Morrison Street
For Sale
1 / 9
$799,000
129 days ago
5124 Morrison Street
Niagara Falls
8 parking
Store W Apt/Office · MLS® X12804136
6978 Optimist Lane
For Sale
1 / 35
$799,000
81 days ago
6978 Optimist Lane
Niagara Falls
3 bd 4 ba 1 parking
Detached · MLS® X12975936
8046 Beaverdams Road
For Sale
1 / 49
$799,000
46 days ago
8046 Beaverdams Road
Niagara Falls
4 bd 4 ba 3 parking
Detached · MLS® X13130116
(905) 830-9111