10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
10 & 11 Methodist Island
1 / 29
29 photos

10 & 11 Methodist Island

Port McNicoll, Tay, ON
Listed 27 days ago
$549,900For Sale
$540,756Estimated value
3Bedrooms
1Bathrooms
700-1100 sqftSize
201 ft × 144 ftLot Size
DetachedProperty Type

10 & 11 Methodist Island

Tay, ON · Port McNicoll

Listed 27 days ago
Bedrooms3
Bathrooms1
Size700-1100 sqft
Lot Size201 ft × 144 ft
Property TypeDetached
$549,900
For Sale
MLS# S13159870
$540,756Estimated value

Polsinello Voice Concierge

Get answers about this home

Ask anything about this home or book a viewing — instantly.

About this home

This charming family cottage offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and classic Georgian Bay living. Inside, the bright open-concept layout features vaulted ceilings, a cozy loft overlooking the kitchen, dining area, and living room, and a wood stove that sets the tone for relaxed evenings after a day outdoors. With 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom, the space is designed for easy family living and effortless hosting. Step outside to a spacious front deck ideal for al fresco meals, morning coffee, or simply taking in the peaceful natural surroundings. The level yard provides room for games and gatherings, while the fire pit invites late-night stories and s'mores under the stars. A separate bunkie-complete with its own screened porch and double bunk beds-offers a fun, private hideaway for ki…

Features & Details

Property Type
Detached
Tax
$3,425 / 2025
Building Age
31-50 years
Size
700-1100 sqft
Lot Size
200.6 x 144.42 Feet
Basement Info
None
Total Parking Spaces
0
Title
Residential Freehold
Property Style
Bungalow-Raised
Community
Port McNicoll
Municipality
Tay
Construction
Wood
Cross Street
Hwy 12 and William St.
Front Door Facing
East
Local Amenities
Beach, Clear View, Island, Lake/Pond, Marina, Waterfront
Lot Legal Description
LOT 10 LOT 11 PLAN PL1186, TAY TOWNSHIP, SIMCOE COUNTY
Data Source
One Point Association of REALTORS
Brokerage
Sotheby's International Realty Canada
Listed On
May 22, 2026
Listing Expires On
Oct 22, 2026
Listing Updated On
May 22, 2026
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1
Kitchens
1
Rooms
7
Bathroom Detail
4 Pcs on Main Level
Driveway
None
Garage Type
None
Parking
0
Heating
Other
Heat Source
Wood
Cooling
None
Sewer
Septic
Fireplace
Wood Stove
Swimming Pool
None
Roof Material
Metal
Foundation Type
Piers
Interior Features
Primary Bedroom - Main Floor

Listing History

Active27 days on marketCurrently viewingMLS #S13159870
May 22, 202627 days ago
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view
Terminated273 days on marketMLS #S12208769
Mar 11, 20263 months ago
Terminated
Sign in to view
Jun 10, 20251 year ago
Listed for Sale
Sign in to view

Estimate History

Estimated value, last 24 months
Jul 2024 – Jun 2026
$574K
$508K
$442K
$376K
Jul
Dec
May
Oct
Mar
Jun

Automated estimate from Polsinello Predictive AI. Not an appraisal. Actual market value may differ.

Mortgage calculator

Estimated monthly payment
$2,683

Estimated payment. Does not include property tax, insurance, or condo fees.

Location & nearby

Port McNicoll Real Estate Market

Tay · last 90 days
$490,000
Median sold price
-4.4%
Median price, year over year
26 days
Avg days on market
8
Homes sold (90 days)
25%
Sold above asking
75%
Sold below asking
$369–$554/ft²
Price per sq ft
Median price trend
Jun 2025 – Jun 2026
$595K
$481K
$366K
$252K
Jun
Sep
Dec
Mar
Jun

Similar homes

39 Meadows Avenue
For Sale
1 / 5
$449,000
11 days ago
39 Meadows Avenue
Tay
Vacant Land · MLS® S13415764
33 Gloucester Grove
For Sale
1 / 30
$449,000
51 days ago
33 Gloucester Grove
Tay
2 bd 1 ba 3 parking
Detached · MLS® S13059510
25 Playfair Drive
For Sale
1 / 48
$455,000
60 days ago
25 Playfair Drive
Tay
2 bd 1 ba 4 parking
Detached · MLS® S13020484
479 Margaret Street
For Sale
1 / 36
$459,900
73 days ago
479 Margaret Street
Tay
2 bd 1 ba 5 parking
Detached · MLS® S12963832
1125 Wood Road
For Sale
1 / 3
$460,777
88 days ago
1125 Wood Road
Tay
Vacant Land · MLS® S12910944
371 William Street
For Sale
1 / 42
$465,000
22 days ago
371 William Street
Tay
2 bd 1 ba 4 parking
Detached · MLS® S13209284
(905) 830-9111